Walkthrough for the mission Who is Not Without Sin in the game Red Dead Redemption 2. This page covers all main objectives, key steps, or helpful tips to guide you through the mission smoothly. Whenever possible, the guide points out locations for key items and details interactions with NPCs, among other tips. To ensure maximum clarity, in-game screenshots are included for easy-to-follow visual guidance.
Quest Group: Chapter 2 - Horseshoe Overlook
Category: Story Mission
Prerequisites: To play this mission, you must first complete the mission Eastward Bound.
In order to start this mission you have to complete the Eastward Bound mission and then talk to Swanson. You'll find him at Flatneck station in the back of one of the buildings.
Hosea told you that Swanson found something down at the train station by the lake.
He's drunk and he plays poker.
Arthur goes to find out what Reverend Swanson is doing at Flatneck Station.
Flatneck Station
World Map
Horseshoe Overlook
World Map
Swanson is drunk and he is not able to continue playing poker and his companions will offer you to take his place. You must play and win at least two hands if you want to earn a gold medal.
Ask the people outside if they know where Swanson went.
They'll point you in the right direction, which narrows down the search area.
Head in this direction and you will soon find Swanson struggling with a large guy.
When you knock down your opponent, you will notice that someone has witnessed a crime you have just committed. The witness will start to run away.
Catch up with him, stop him and convince him to stay silent. You can also shoot him.
After a while you will notice that Reverend Swanson went on "a trip" to the railway bridge. Run to him as quickly as you can.
Looks like Reverend Swanson's leg is stuck in the track. In addition, a train is coming. Release his leg from the trap before the train hits you.
When you are safe, still drunk and unaware of what might have happened, Reverend Swanson will fall asleep next to the tracks.
Pick up the drunken Reverend Swanson from the ground, put him up on horseback, and head back to your camp as fast as possible. To earn a gold medal it can't take you more than 2 minutes 5 seconds.
Hitch the horse, remove Revered Swanson from the horse and take him to his tent. The Reverend's gonna need some sleep.
When you deliver Swanson to his bed, the mission will be over.
After completing this mission, you will be able to play the mission Smoking and Other Hobbies.