Walkthrough for the mission We Loved Once and True I - III in the game Red Dead Redemption 2. This page covers all main objectives, key steps, or helpful tips to guide you through the mission smoothly. Whenever possible, the guide points out locations for key items and details interactions with NPCs, among other tips. To ensure maximum clarity, in-game screenshots are included for easy-to-follow visual guidance.
Quest Group: Chapter 2 - Horseshoe Overlook
Category: Story Mission
At some point in the game, Arthur will receive a letter from his old love, Mary Linton. The letter will be waiting for him in the camp on the table in his tent.
Arthur receives a letter from an old friend, Mary.
Read the letter from Mary Linton. Mary needs your help and asks for a meeting.
A new marker will appear on the map, pointing to Chadwick Farm just a bit north of Valentine.
Mary Linton requested your help in her letter.
Go to Chadwick Farm and talk to Mary.
She will ask you for your help in the rescue of her younger brother from the Chelonians cult.
Mary needs your help bringing her brother Jamie home from a cult called the 'Chelonians'.
Travel to the hill, where the Chelonians gather to worship.
After finding Jamie in Cumberland Forest with the Chelonian religious order, Arthur tries to convince him to return to Mary.
Approach the worshipers. Cult members won't let you get close to Jamie. You have to convince them to let you do it.
If you want to do this peacefully, you must give the following answers to their questions:
Unfortunately, Jamie himself still doesn't want to talk to you and will start running away.
Get on your horse and chase after him.
Follow him until you reach the railroad tracks. Jamie will cross the tracks just before the train arrives, and you won't be able to do the same.
Jamie won't go any further, he'll stop and start talking to you. When the train passes and you can cross to the other side of the track, Jamie will threaten to shoot himself and draw his gun.
Draw your gun and shoot the gun out of Jamie's hand before he kills himself.
Jamie will finally understand that you want his good and will decide to go back to his sister with you.
Mary will be waiting for you at the train station in Valentine. Remember that if you want to get a gold medal, you only have 2 minutes. The shortest and quickest way to the station goes along the railway tracks.
Finally, you say goodbye to them, Mary and Jamie will get on the train and leave.
