Loyalty, Discipline, and Courage

This is the second quest you must complete to get Padre to join your crew. It starts automatically after completing the "A Second Chance" quest.

1. Investigate Du Casse's men

Hint:

• Travel to Cumberland Bay

Head to Cumberland Bay. It is best to approach it from the southeast side.

Du Casse's men are in a camp on the southeastern side of the island, so it is best to go ashore somewhere nearby.

2. Investigate the camp

There are only four of Du Casse's men here: one by the campfire, another on the beach in front of the camp entrance, and two inside the camp itself. Eliminate them in whatever way suits you best.

Hint:

• Read the letter

Enter the camp and read the letter pinned with a knife to a green barrel.

3. Return to the Padre

The fast travel option to Caracol will be locked, so you must sail there on your ship. As you get closer, you will see three ships with Du Casse's men sailing away.

Go ashore - the village has been ransacked - and head to the place where you previously met Dinah. You will find the Padre praying there.

A cutscene will trigger in which the Padre, experiencing a crisis of faith, decides to seek revenge on the killers and joins your crew as a Master-at-Arms. This unlocks a new ability to use during naval battles.

After the cutscene this quest will end, and the next one will unlock - If Thy Right Hand Offend Thee.