Walkthrough for the mission No, No and Thrice, No in the game Red Dead Redemption 2. This page covers all main objectives, key steps, or helpful tips to guide you through the mission smoothly. Whenever possible, the guide points out locations for key items and details interactions with NPCs, among other tips. To ensure maximum clarity, in-game screenshots are included for easy-to-follow visual guidance.
Quest Group: Chapter 4 - Saint Denis
Category: Story Mission
Prerequisites: To play this mission, you must first complete the mission The Joys of Civilization.
After completing The Joys of Civilization mission you will be able to talk to Mary-Beth at your camp in Shady Belle.
Your conversation will be interrupted by Susan who will inform you that Tilly has been taken and ask for help in her rescue.
Susan and Arthur head to the Foreman Brothers' hideout to rescue Tilly, who has been kidnapped.
Shady Belle
World Map
Get on the wagon and drive to Radley's House just outside of Rhodes.
When you get there, you'll meet one guard outside the house. Susan will come up to him and suddenly stab him in the neck.
Break the lock or kick the door, get into the house and kill the guy in the first room.
Kick the door to the next room.There you will find Tilly and another armed guy. Kill him too.
Free Tilly. She will tell you that there are more enemies behind the house.
When you go outside through the back door, you will notice three more enemies who have mounted their horses and are riding away.
You and Susan get together on a horse standing nearby and you start chasing the bandits.
You're the one who has to shoot them in order to earn the gold medal so don't get too close to them, as Susan will shoot them. Activate Dead Eye and kill the first two riders from the distance. Don't forget that you also need high accuracy to earn the gold medal.
The last of the gang members, their leader, you have to catch with a lasso.
Tie him up, put him on the horse and go back to Tilly.
When you get back to Tilly, get Anthony off the horse and drop him on the ground in front of the women.
Tilly wants to spare Anthony and Susan suggests slitting his throat. The final decision will be up to you.
Once you've made your decision, the mission will end and you'll acquire a new horse.
After completing this mission, you will be able to play the mission Horsemen, Apocalypses.