A total of 18 Found and Lost can be found in the game. These are 9 different items, each of them in two versions - Found & Lost. You get half of them after completing side quests and you can get the other half by fishing them out in specific places.
Once you find all the Lost and Found and put them on the shelf in the hut, you will unlock the "Both Sides" achievement / trophy.
Fables withered by time, their meanings lost and found anew.
Candle (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Candle (Reward)This is the reward for completing the quest "The Void Stares Back".
Cobbler's Tool (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Cobbler's Tool (Reward)It's a reward for completing the "Maneater" quest.
Fake Sheep (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
The Dragon Slayer, Pt. 2
...his reign however did not last long, as the real reason behind his brother’s demise has become a burden too heavy to bear.
As the dragon perished its lair caved in, trapping the brothers inside. Soon after came whispers from the dark. Something slithered down the walls.
The voice from the deep spoke of the throne – only one of the brothers could take it, and now was the perfect occasion for only one to be left alive. The heroes resisted the whispers for long, enough but as the hours went by, their will grew weaker. Then, one moment one of the brothers snapped.
When the rubble was removed, only one of them emerged alive. The newly-crowned king never ceased to hear the whispers, however. Day by day they drove him mad, as he heard his late brother’s voice among them. When it became too much for him, he took his own life, using the very blade that spilled his brother’s blood.
Fake Sheep (Reward)Related quests: There Be Dragons
This is the reward you will receive after completing the "There Be Dragons" quest.
The Dragon Slayer, Pt. 1
Once upon a time, there was a fearsome dragon. No knight nor hunter could ever best the beast and its appetite grew by the day. And as more and more of the king’s men lost their lives to the beast, his sons decided to prove their valor.
They challenged the beast and, after a long and exhausting fight, slew it. The kingdom regaled in joy but sadly, only one of the heroes survived to tell the tale. For his bravery and wit, he was then named a king...
Honey Covered Pickaxe (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Honey-Covered Pickaxe (Reward)You will receive this item after defeating the first wave of enemies attacking the quarry during the quest "Quarrel in the Quarry".
Ice Shard (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Ice Shard (Reward)This is the reward for completing the quest "On the Shoulders of Giants".
Poisoned Apple (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Poisoned Apple (Reward)Related quests: Who's the Fairest of Them Gnoll?
This is the reward for completing the quest "Who's the Fairest of Them Gnoll?".
Spindle (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Spindle (Reward)Related quests: Until It Sleeps
This is a reward for completing the "Until It Sleeps" quest.
Stone (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Stone (Reward)This is the reward for completing the quest "Stone Wars".
Wolf Skull (Fishing)To get this item you have to fish it from the fishing spot located here.
Wolf Skull (Reward)This is the reward for completing the quest "Three Little Seeds".